reflections on the GI Conference

What is Food Addiction and How is it Diagnosed?

A 5-part series on Food Addiction.

Last year I resurrected my most popular blog posts from the past and right at the tippy top was my post on food addiction. And I received resounding feedback that many of you would like a food addiction update from me. Interestingly, this is something I’ve been working on in the background for a separate project.

Given the complex interplay between dieting, dietary restriction, and food addiction, I thought this was a great time. I am going to write 5 newsletters on the topic of food addiction, even though that only scratches the surface on this complex topic. 

Here’s what you can expect from this 5-part series on Food Addiction:

  1. What is food addiction? How is it diagnosed? (Today’s newsletter.)
  2. Linking dietary restriction and food addiction
  3. Evolutions in the food addiction research landscape: then and now
  4. Critique and concerns
  5. Particular considerations for the eating disorder profession

Before I dive in I’d like to offer a few things to you, dear reader.

  • If this topic is activating for you due to your own lived experience, consider whether it is best for your well-being to keep reading. Many people, particularly individuals in larger bodies, have experienced profound harm from other people foisting the food addiction framework onto them. Please take care of yourself first.
  • Notice your capacity to remain open-hearted and curious. This is a hotly debated topic in my professional circles. Engaging with tough topics is important yet challenging work.
  • This topic is profoundly nuanced and complex, so much so that it feels hard to distill my own thoughts to a reasonable word count over 5 newsletters!
  • I intend to write for a mostly professional/clinical audience yet will strive to integrate the lived/felt experience. But the content will be mostly scientific/research-based.

Engaging with complex, even activating topics, is an important part of our clinical work.

What is food addiction?

Well, it’s tricky! It really depends on who you ask because of the lack of consensus. 

Most recently, proponents of the food addiction framework have shifted to utilizing the phrase “Ultra Processed Food Addiction” (UPFA). This level of specificity matters because they are pointing to it being a substance addiction akin to drugs, alcohol, nicotine as opposed to a behavioral addiction (e.g. gambling, shopping, pornography). 

Researchers have yet to elucidate which specific ingredients are able to trigger UPFA in susceptible individuals but typically point to Class 4 foods in the Nova Classification system. Proponents of this approach point to specific ways foods have been engineered to create potent food concentrations which enter the bloodstream rapidly and produce a high level of salience, similar to what amplifies addictive potential in other substances like nicotine (Gearhardt & DiFeliceantonio 2022). 

A reasonable definition of UPFA: the development of compulsive behaviors and cravings for ultra-processed foods (UPFs), often involving intense cravings, inability to control intake, and withdrawal symptoms when consumption is reduced.

How is Ultra Processed Food Addiction diagnosed?

Proponents of the UPFA model point to 3 areas of data to develop a “diagnosis” of UPFA. I put this in quotes due to the lack of consensus on this issue. This includes subjective experience, behavioral symptoms, and engagement of brain regions related to reward and motivation (Gearhardt and Schulte 2021). David Wiss and colleagues have done important work highlighting the complex ways a person may “appear” addicted when in reality, what we are seeing is an adaptive response to starvation or periods of dietary restriction (Wiss and Brewerton 2020). 

As a primer for next week’s exploration on food addiction and dietary restriction, I’d like to invite you to consider the following questions:

  1. If you have your own history of an eating disorder or disordered eating, did you ever feel addicted to or out of control with food? Did you ever feel that your eating did not align with your personal values? Consider downloading the Yale Food Addiction Scale 2.0 (rather than the modified version) and reading through the questions.
  2. If you have your own history of an eating disorder or disordered eating, can you recall whether your food troubles began with dietary restriction or compulsive overeating or binge eating?
  3. A food addiction diagnosis utilizing the Yale Food Addiction Scale provides prevalence rates in the US around 14-15% in the general population. But in the ED population prevalence rates are as high as 97% (Meule and Gearhardt 2019, Gearhardt 2021, Wiss 2022, LaFata 2024). Why do you think those numbers are so high in the ED population?

I hope this offers you a very basic overview of definitions and concepts. I’m excited to dive deeper over the next 4 weeks. My intention is to provide you with a reasonably objective description of the current literature and will save my clinical opinions and interpretation for later on in the series. I hope this will allow you the opportunity to critically engage with the material on your own terms.

Thanks for being here with me!

marci evans RD boston MA

 

 

 

 

Check out the other articles in this 5-part series on Food Addiction:

 

Citations:

  • Gearhardt, A. N., & DiFeliceantonio, A. G. (2022). Highly processed foods can be considered addictive substances based on established scientific criteria. Addiction, 118(4). https://doi.org/10.1111/add.16065
  • Gearhardt, A. N., & Schulte, E. M. (2021). Is Food Addictive? A Review of the Science. Annual Review of Nutrition, 41(1), 387–410. https://doi.org/10.1146/annurev-nutr-110420-111710
  • Wiss, D., & Brewerton, T. (2020). Separating the Signal from the Noise: How Psychiatric Diagnoses Can Help Discern Food Addiction from Dietary Restraint. Nutrients, 12(10), 2937. https://doi.org/10.3390/nu12102937